My Book
A different view of the justice system
Tuesday, June 9, 2015
Thursday, June 4, 2015
The "Scopes Monkey Trial" Facts vs Fiction
In the debate between supporters of Darwin's theory of evolution and the "ignorant anti-science" masses, the Scopes Monkey Trial is probably the most iconic symbol of the struggle. Many, if not most, of those familiar with the trial base their knowledge on the 1960 film Inherit the Wind. As with any Hollywood production, the historical facts tend to be discarded in favor of entertainment.
According to the film version, an honorable and brave high school biology teacher is thrown in jail and prosecuted for teaching evolution. The action is in response to the mob mentality of Christian fundamentalist who want him lynched for daring to teach contrary to the holy scriptures.
The real story of the trial is told by Edward Larson in his book Summer for the Gods and he describes a publicity stunt created by the ACLU in New York and by the civic leaders of Dayton Tennessee, the town where the trial was held. Dayton's leaders wanted to drum up publicity for the town and Scopes was a willing participant in the scheme. Scopes never spent a minute in jail and was good friends with the prosecutor. He was a substitute teacher, not a biology teacher, and had never taught evolution. After the trial, the school offered to renew Scopes' teaching contract.
In the summer of 1925, Darwin's theory of evolution was a hot issue. Margaret Sanger (founder of Planned Parenthood) was using the topic of natural selection to justify her pet cause of eugenics. Eugenics was also taken up by the militarists in Germany (Nazis) as a way to develop a master race. The most important "expert witnesses" the defense considered calling were proponents of forced eugenics.
In 1925 a few states had passed laws prohibiting the teaching of evolution but none of them attached any punishment to the violation. Tennessee's law was a misdemeanor and upon signing it the Governor had declared that it could never be enforced. It may very well have remained that way but for the idea of a native New Yorker who'd recently moved to Dayton. George Rappleyyea had read in a newspaper that the ACLU was offering to defend any Tennessee teacher who violated the law.
Rappleyea decided this would be an excellent way for Dayton to get national publicity and he took the idea to the town leadership assembled at the local drugstore. The town leaders agreed this would be an excellent way to put the town on the map. Even the school superintendent, who had supported the law, liked the idea. The ACLU subsequently signed on and agreed to pay the costs for the prosecution and the defense.
All they needed now was a teacher who would admit to having taught evolution and a prosecutor willing to take the case. One of the town's prosecutors was friends with a 24 year old substitute teacher, John Scopes, who sometimes taught biology. There was only a small problem. Scopes couldn't remember if he'd ever taught evolution.
The pharmacist pulled a popular biology book off his shelf, Hunter's Civic Biology, and asked Scopes if he had ever used it to prepare for class when he substituted for the regular biology teacher. Scopes replied that he had and the pharmacists excitedly proclaimed that the book mentioned evolution and Scopes could be their defendant.
Scopes cheerfully admitted to violating the law and a warrant for his arrest was sworn out. The school superintendent excitedly proclaimed that "Something has happened that's going to put Dayton on the Map!"
Publicity flyers were soon rushed to New York announcing the trial on evolution. Both defense and prosecution were eager to get the case to trial before another town beat them to the punch and stole their glory. Two well known blowhards were hired to represent both sides-William Jennings Bryan for the prosecution and Clarence Darrow for the defense.
Dayton civic leaders formed a Scopes Trial Entertainment Committee to plan activities around the trial. Tents were erected for shows and extra trains were requested for the expected crowds. A carnival atmosphere engulfed the town. Shop windows displayed monkeys and the sheriff put a sign on his motorcycle that said "Monkeyville Police."
The trial itself was excellent theatre with both sides playing their parts dramatically. Scopes was eventually found guilty of the misdemeanor and given a $100 fine, which Bryan offered to pay. The Tennessee Supreme Court upheld the law but threw out the conviction on a technicality. Scopes called the dismissal of his conviction a "disappointment." Meanwhile the ACLU sought to have another trial challenging any anti-evolution law in any state. There were no takers.
To this day many people bring up the specter of the Scopes Monkey Trial to portray "anti-science, Christian fundamentalist, yahoos" run amok.
Monday, June 1, 2015
Political Unity for Criminal Justice Reform. Cause to Rejoice?
People from across the political spectrum have joined
together in a rare case of unity on the issue of criminal justice reform. This is both promising and discouraging at
the same time. It’s promising because
our justice system needs change and improvement but it’s discouraging because
current efforts follow the same tired design as previous attempts.
As always, “mass incarceration” is branded as the primary
problem. Too much incarceration as a
basis for criminal justice reform is as misguided as too much hospitalization
as a basis for healthcare reform. Intentionally
reducing incarceration will not improve the system but will potentially do more
harm than good.
What’s being discussed is more legislation to amend
sentencing laws and create better responses to crime. “Better” meaning those that don’t result in
incarceration. This reactive approach of
making the system kinder and gentler or meaner and harsher (depending on the
political climate) on offenders after
they commit a crime keeps us in a perpetual state of conflict and distraction
from real solutions.
Punishment and rehabilitation are two sides of the same
coin—the individual offender and the best responses to their actions. This focus on the offender rather than on a
holistic view of community safety is a major part of the problem. Policies designed to be tough on crime, soft
on crime, and the latest “smart on crime” really have nothing to do with crime
at all.
The reason we don’t have an effective crime policy is that
we think we’re discussing crime when
were actually talking about individual criminal
behavior. The inability to
distinguish the two keeps us constantly debating about the best ways to respond
to criminal acts. We then throw money at
the perceived problem or expend political capital in order to generate more and
better programs rather than effective strategies.
Crime is the host environment in which criminal acts occur. Crime can be identified by specific locations
within communities and geographic boundaries.
Proactive strategies to prevent, confront, and reduce crime can then be
devised. Those strategies must be
implemented from the ground up at the neighborhood level rather than the
current top down approach from legislatures and courts.
California started reducing its prison population in 2011
because of a court order and Proposition 47.
The November 2014 voter approved proposition reduces penalties for
certain crimes and reclassifies from felonies to misdemeanors other
“non-serious and non-violent property and drug crimes”. These changes were in response to
California’s perceived mass incarceration and prison crowding problem.
After releasing thousands of inmates in response to the
court order, property and violent crimes increased in 40 of California's 69
largest cities in the first six months of 2012, the largest such increase in 20
years. Remaining to be seen is the full
effect of implementing the citizens’ demands of Proposition 47.
No one considered that California, like the rest of our
country, has about 70% of its corrections population under community supervision
rather than in prisons. The real
corrections crowding is in community corrections where probation officers
struggle with huge caseloads making effective supervision virtually impossible.
California fits a national reform narrative stating that in
addition to mass incarceration prisons hold large numbers of “non-violent
offenders” who can and should be released.
This raises several questions.
Should we never incarcerate non-violent offenders such as
burglars, swindlers, and others? What
exactly is a non-violent offender?
Someone who committed a non-violent crime? Is it someone who committed a non-violent
crime but with a history of violence? Or
is it someone who committed a violent crime that was plea-bargained down to a
non-violent crime?
Daron Wint, who was arrested for the quadruple murder of a
Washington DC family and their housekeeper was convicted of assaulting a
girlfriend in Maryland in 2009. He then
pleaded guilty the next year to malicious destruction of property (a
non-violent crime) after he allegedly threatened to kill a woman and her infant
daughter, breaking into her apartment, stealing a television and vandalizing
her car.
Also in 2010, Wint was arrested carrying a 2-foot-long
machete and a BB pistol outside the American Iron Works headquarters, but
weapons charges were dropped after he pleaded guilty to possessing an open
container of alcohol (another non-violent crime).
The point is that a person’s current offense doesn’t paint a
complete picture of the offender. It’s
dishonest to suggest that our prisons are filled with non-violent offenders
guilty of only drug violations. Al
Capone’s only major sentence was for tax evasion and he had a history of illegal
booze violations.
These things are never taken into account by policymakers
and reformers working to reduce prison crowding by releasing scores of
“non-violent” and “low-level” offenders. The criminal justice reform movement is
essentially an anti-incarceration movement.
Rather than fashioning a system to create and maintain safer communities
it strives to make the system a gatekeeper for prisons.
The term “mass incarceration” is meaningless. The fact is that incarceration in our country
is an alternative sanction. We have the vast majority of offenders (more
than 80% in some states) under community supervision rather than locked up.
Within a corrections population of about 7 million, close to 5 million
are under community supervision.
Probation alone comprises about 4 million.
Reformers don’t seem to understand that calling for greater
use of alternative sentences is demanding that the system do what it’s already
doing.
With our attention focused on the relatively few in prison
(compared to the entire corrections population) we loose sight of the overall
picture. This causes reliance on a
flawed success measure--recidivism. The
fact that someone hasn’t returned to prison tells us very little. Is it because they've reformed or is it
because they haven't gotten caught? Someone can continue to victimize others while
avoiding incarceration.
Our fixation on recidivism creates problems. Probation and parole officers are often
instructed not to revoke anyone until they murder or seriously harm someone. With certain offenders, numerous crimes can be
prevented by certain and swift recommitment—even for minor offenses.
Reducing recidivism is extremely easy. Simply have probation and parole officers
stop revoking anyone until they kill at least two people. Judges likewise shouldn’t sentence ex-cons
to prison until they kill at least two people.
The recidivism rate would plummet, but at what cost?
The system needs to change its focus away from the
individual offender. It should strive to
create and maintain safer communities by confronting and preventing crime
rather than strive to reduce or increase incarceration. It must be evaluated on its reduction of
victimization rather than reduction of recidivism. Punishment and rehabilitation must be viewed
as means toward the goal rather than as solutions. We
should have a more valuable system rather than a costlier or cheaper one.
This means the system doesn’t need reformation. It needs transformation. Transformation is different from perpetual
reform efforts that simply change the pendulum swing from punishment to rehabilitation.
Misguided policy is often the result of “panels of experts”
providing policymakers answers to problems.
That’s all well and good. We have
to realize however that it’s not about the answers. It’s about asking the crucial questions. We must start asking those questions now.
Monday, April 27, 2015
The Yogi Berra Approach to Criminal Justice Reform
The great New York Yankees catcher, Yogi Berra, was once asked why he no longer went to Ruggeri's, a St. Louis restaurant. He's reply was a classic in what became known as "Yogiisms."
"Nobody goes there anymore. It's too crowded."
The American public developed an affectionate soft spot for the unassuming sports hero and his non-pendantic musings. He made sense without making any sense--a rare gift indeed. Yogiisms are uniquely suited to the master himself but policy makers should steer clear of attempting to model their work using the same logic. The current approach to criminal justice reform is a good example.
Criminal justice system reform is itself a type of misnomer. The reform efforts are not focused so much on the justice system as they are on prisons. The ultimate goal of the work is to reduce incarceration and prison crowding. The problem with this approach is that the results are always the same. After people finish congratulating themselves for changing laws designed to send fewer people to prison they create a situation resulting in no one ever going there anymore (prison) because it's too crowded.
Next comes the reforms to reform the reforms. The prisons are still as over crowded as or not that much different than before. Even if changes result in fewer people going to prison and the state closes a few institutions, those that remain open are eventually designated over crowded and in need of further reform. The reform industry never lacks business.
The reason for this is because of focusing on the wrong problem. The problem isn't that we have too many people incarcerated and not enough alternatives to incarceration. The fact is that we have the vast majority of offenders (more than eighty percent in some states) under community supervision rather than locked up. Continuous calls from reformers for greater use of "alternatives to incarceration" are thus demands that the system do what it's already doing and has been doing for decades.
In the last two to three decades states have implemented what are known as intermediate sanctions or intermediate punishments. These are correctional programs somewhere between the intense control of incarceration and the lax control of probation. These programs include things like house arrest with or without electronic monitoring, work release programs, and day reporting centers where offenders spend part of the day receiving drug treatment and various needed social services.
These are intended to be diversion programs to divert people away from incarceration but what happens too often is that not many people are actually diverted, at least not from prison. Since the vast majority of offenders are under community supervision and more specifically probation, most cases diverted to these programs would have ended up on probation if the programs were not available. The criteria for acceptance into these programs also favors those who would otherwise end up on probation. The prison population thus remains roughly the same while legislators can claim that "nobody goes there anymore."
Criminal justice reform will remain spinning its wheels in an endless cycle of repeating its prior attempts to improve the system unless it focuses on the true nature of the problem. The system doesn't need more alternatives to incarceration because incarceration, in our country, is an alternative sanction. Within a corrections population of about seven million, about five million are under community supervision. Probation alone makes up about four and one half million of the community supervision population.
It seems that what we need are alternatives to probation because probation is the preferred sanction in our country. With Conservatives, Liberals, and Libertarians joining forces in a rare case of unity around criminal justice reform, we seem to be approaching a fork in the road regarding how to approach the problem. And as the master once said: "When you come to a fork in the road, take it."
"Nobody goes there anymore. It's too crowded."
The American public developed an affectionate soft spot for the unassuming sports hero and his non-pendantic musings. He made sense without making any sense--a rare gift indeed. Yogiisms are uniquely suited to the master himself but policy makers should steer clear of attempting to model their work using the same logic. The current approach to criminal justice reform is a good example.
Criminal justice system reform is itself a type of misnomer. The reform efforts are not focused so much on the justice system as they are on prisons. The ultimate goal of the work is to reduce incarceration and prison crowding. The problem with this approach is that the results are always the same. After people finish congratulating themselves for changing laws designed to send fewer people to prison they create a situation resulting in no one ever going there anymore (prison) because it's too crowded.
Next comes the reforms to reform the reforms. The prisons are still as over crowded as or not that much different than before. Even if changes result in fewer people going to prison and the state closes a few institutions, those that remain open are eventually designated over crowded and in need of further reform. The reform industry never lacks business.
The reason for this is because of focusing on the wrong problem. The problem isn't that we have too many people incarcerated and not enough alternatives to incarceration. The fact is that we have the vast majority of offenders (more than eighty percent in some states) under community supervision rather than locked up. Continuous calls from reformers for greater use of "alternatives to incarceration" are thus demands that the system do what it's already doing and has been doing for decades.
In the last two to three decades states have implemented what are known as intermediate sanctions or intermediate punishments. These are correctional programs somewhere between the intense control of incarceration and the lax control of probation. These programs include things like house arrest with or without electronic monitoring, work release programs, and day reporting centers where offenders spend part of the day receiving drug treatment and various needed social services.
These are intended to be diversion programs to divert people away from incarceration but what happens too often is that not many people are actually diverted, at least not from prison. Since the vast majority of offenders are under community supervision and more specifically probation, most cases diverted to these programs would have ended up on probation if the programs were not available. The criteria for acceptance into these programs also favors those who would otherwise end up on probation. The prison population thus remains roughly the same while legislators can claim that "nobody goes there anymore."
Criminal justice reform will remain spinning its wheels in an endless cycle of repeating its prior attempts to improve the system unless it focuses on the true nature of the problem. The system doesn't need more alternatives to incarceration because incarceration, in our country, is an alternative sanction. Within a corrections population of about seven million, about five million are under community supervision. Probation alone makes up about four and one half million of the community supervision population.
It seems that what we need are alternatives to probation because probation is the preferred sanction in our country. With Conservatives, Liberals, and Libertarians joining forces in a rare case of unity around criminal justice reform, we seem to be approaching a fork in the road regarding how to approach the problem. And as the master once said: "When you come to a fork in the road, take it."
Friday, February 13, 2015
What's with the "E" question?
Now that Scott walker is the front runner for the Republican Presidential nomination the scramble is on to show that he's just another dumb, anti-science, white guy. During a recent interview on a trip to London, he was asked if he believed in "E-volution." Walker chose to punt and refused to answer the question. Here's how I think he should have answered:
"I don't understand the question.''
"Are you referring to Micro or Macro evolution? Microevolution refers to varieties within a given type. Change happens within a group, but the descendant is clearly of the same type as the ancestor. This might better be called variation, or adaptation, but the changes are "horizontal" in effect, not "vertical." The proof of micro evolution is undeniable. For example, humans have evolved into different races and today's humans are larger than their ancestors."
"Macroevolution refers to major evolutionary changes over time, the origin of new types of organisms from previously existing, but different, ancestral types. Macroevolution remains a theory and has yet to be conclusively proven. I'll now be happy to answer any questions directly related to my qualifications for elected office."
Saturday, February 7, 2015
Tuesday, December 16, 2014
In the 1995 movie Heat,
Lt. Vincent Hanna, played by Al Pacino, confronts bank robber Neil McCuley,
played by Robert De Niro. Hanna says to McCauley, “Seven years
in Folsom. In the hole for three. McNeil before that. McNeil as tough as they
say?”
I found myself feeling a twinge of pride at the mention of the place
where I learned and gained so much.
If it was as tough as they say, it wasn’t because of harsh treatment
from the correctional officers. They went about their thankless tasks with
professionalism and dignity. Between the occasional moments of alarm and
confrontations with disruptive inmates were months of peaceful interactions
between staff and prisoners.
These officers never became demoralized. Part of the reason for this
was because of the bonds of camaraderie we formed through our shared and lack-of-acclaim
jobs. Maybe it’s because many officers were retired from the military,
were more mature in years and experience, or I’m just biased, but the
correctional officer force at McNeil Island was among the best, if not the best, I saw throughout my career. I’m
proud to have been a part of not only the McNeil Island staff but also the
Bureau of Prisons staff.
The McNeil Island prison is now long gone. In 1981, the BOP turned
over operations to Washington State, and McNeil Island became a state
prison. In 2011, it closed for good,
marking the end of an era.
I mention this because, of all the justice components targeted
by reformers, the prison system is the most maligned. Prisons are portrayed in
a negative light in most, if not all, accounts available to the public. Prison
guards are always portrayed as not much better, if not altogether worse, than
the inmates.
There are many of us who know better, but our
voices are never heard.
-From THE QUIET REVOLUTION, Shattering the myths about the American Criminal Justice System-
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
